City Cast Chicago logo

Inside Chicago’s Role in Beanie Babie Mania

Posted on July 31, 2023   |   Updated on September 30, 2025
Sidney Madden

Sidney Madden

Beanie Babies creator Ty Warner

Beanie Babies creator Ty Warner in New York City in 2003. (Chris Hondros / Getty)

Thirty years after Beanie Babies were introduced to the world, a new film is out depicting the rise and fall of the plush toy empire and its eccentric Chicagoland creator.

Who is Ty Warner?

Before the LaGrange native was known as a reclusive billionaire, he was a toy salesman who got fired for selling his own products on the side. After seeing plush toy cats abroad, Warner returned to Chicagoland to launch Beanie Babies, Chicago magazine reported.

A table of Beanie Babies

A table of Beanie Babies in 2002. (Lea Suzuki / San Francisco Chronicle / Getty)

What made Beanie Babies so special?

The toys were stuffed with plastic pellets, which gave them more mobility than other toys on the market. 

But they were so popular in the ‘90s because Warner would amp up demand by routinely retiring animals, putting out limited stock, and being selective where the toys were sold. Collectors on eBay went wild. A $5 toy could be valued for a couple thousand dollars.

The frenzy was worldwide: Ty Inc. pulled $1.4 billion in 1998, according to Morning Brew. In Oak Brook, where Warner lived, seeing 100 parents outside a toy store wasn’t unusual.

But all good things must come to an end …

As demand waned, Warner announced in 1999 all toys would be retired but reversed course and brought them back. Interest wasn't the same though.

Warner has since been convicted for tax evasion, faced abuse allegations from a former partner, and has been caught up in legal disputes with luxury hotels he owns.

And the film?

Based on Zac Bissonnette’s book of the same name, some critics are taking issue with the fictional liberties filmmakers took. Others are unimpressed with yet another movie about a commercial product without much thoughtful critique.

+ Speaking of films with Chicago connections, we explored the local sneakerhead scene after “Air” was released.

Share article

Hey Chicago

Stay connected to City Cast Chicago and get ready to join the local conversation.

Can't subscribe? Turn off your ad blocker and try again.

The latest in Chicago

Keep It LocalSeptember 10

Sheep Cult Comics Celebrates Local Chicago Comic Artists

Stepping into Sheep Cult Comics, you’re surrounded by whimsical, winding caverns of cloud-like shelves, presided over by sculpted sheep h...

A large entrance in a store in the shape of a sheep. There are books along both sides of it
Keep It LocalSeptember 10

Your Guide To Chicago’s Comic Book Stores

I’ve compiled a list of stores where you can find the newest graphic novels, affordable used comics, or even your next favorite board gam...

Comics on display in what looks to be a multicolored customized bookshelf
Keep It LocalSeptember 3

Your Guide To Karaoke Bars in Chicago

Whether your perfect karaoke night involves performing to an entire bar or renting a room for a more intimate experience, you’ve got opti...

A woman singing into a mic. A man is holding up what looks to be a tv screen
Keep It LocalSeptember 3

The Art of Karaoke

Karaoke is pretty serious business, and I want to make sure you know what you’re getting yourself into.

A woman singing into a mic with her finger pointed up. There's a man behind her holding a screen
Neighborhood GuidesSeptember 1

Your Guide to September 2026 in Chicago

A guide to things to do in Chicago in September 2026

Three excited men, The one in the left is in regular clothes and is smiling and clapping. The one in the middle is in a football jersey with a cheese grater hat. He is yelling and grating cheese. The one on the right is laughing and also wearing a cheese grater hat
Keep It LocalAugust 27

How To Start Growing Your Own Food

Amid a summer of foodborne illnesses, intense weather, and ever-rising grocery prices, many Chicagoans are exploring ways to grow their o...

A man in a bucket hat and glasses holding vegetables in a large garden
Keep It LocalAugust 27

Your Guide To Chicago’s Garden Shops

From expansive gardening centers to little shops packed with houseplants, it’s not hard to find all the supplies you need to bring some m...

A garden with an assortment of big leafed plants
Keep It LocalAugust 20

How Transit Tees Turns Chicago’s Quirks Into Board Games

From board games about the city’s history to puzzles of iconic maps to card decks featuring local wildlife, Transit Tees’ teams of creato...

A person writing on a gridded paper that says "Chicago 1893" There's also a board game with an assortment of different houses for the board game on it. There is also A bowl of popcorn and a soda on the table