City Cast Chicago logo

Tough Grades for Mayor Brandon Johnson's First Year

Posted on May 20, 2024   |   Updated on September 30, 2025
Simone Alicea

Simone Alicea

A D- report card for Mayor Brandon Johnson

Hey Chicago readers and City Cast Chicago listeners gave the first-term mayor a D- 😬 (City Cast Chicago)

City Cast

Why Mayor Brandon Johnson Won't Grade His First Year

00:00:00

After the City Cast Chicago podcast talked with Mayor Brandon Johnson last week, we gave him about a C- grade on his first year in office.

City Cast

Trump Tower Tax Trouble, Mayor’s Grades, and a Cicada Costume

00:00:00

The main reasons for low marks? Concerns about crime, transit, migrants, transparency, and overall leadership. Here’s what you said about his performance.

A pie chart showing nearly half of Hey Chicago readers gave Mayor Brandon Johnson a failing grade

Nearly half of readers and listeners who participated in our survey gave a failing grade. (City Cast Chicago)

Grade F

Colette W.: “He bumbles along and ‘reacts’ versus instituting proactive policies regarding crime, especially in high-tourist areas and city central neighborhoods.”

Grade D

Hannah F.: “Failure to accomplish anything of note, while serious issues continue to get worse. The state of public transit is my biggest concern, and he’s been atrocious in my opinion.”

City Cast

CTA Investigation, Counting Migrant Students, and Bears Stadium Plans

00:00:00

Sten T.: “As someone who voted for and knocked doors for [Johnson], I want to know who he’s listening to because it’s not the people who showed up for him a year ago.”

City Cast

Brandon Johnson Says Chicago Needs a Teacher at City Hall

00:00:00

Grade C

Hilary M.: “I think he has focused on less urgent matters and allowed himself to be manipulated (e.g. the ridiculous request for a new [Bears] stadium).”

City Cast

CTA Investigation, Counting Migrant Students, and Bears Stadium Plans

00:00:00

Matt M.: “I think overall there have been some progressive wins that were promised, but some administrative bumbling that has been disappointing.”

Grade B

Viral M.: “Ending tipped minimum wage … passed a huge housing bond deal to wean us off TIFs … took cops out of schools … reopened the Department of Environment … I think he needs to be better about communications and transparency in general, but he’s following through on a lot of the things he said he’d do.”

City Cast

Why is Chicago Always Talking About TIF?

00:00:00

Share article

Hey Chicago

Stay connected to City Cast Chicago and get ready to join the local conversation.

Can't subscribe? Turn off your ad blocker and try again.

The latest in Chicago

Chicago, ExplainedAugust 21

Take This Week's Chicago News Trivia Quiz

How closely were you paying attention to this week's current events in Chicago? Test yourself in our weekly trivia quiz.

A man in a cubs uniform bracing for a man in a white sox stealing a base
Keep It LocalAugust 20

How Transit Tees Turns Chicago’s Quirks Into Board Games

From board games about the city’s history to puzzles of iconic maps to card decks featuring local wildlife, Transit Tees’ teams of creato...

A person writing on a gridded paper that says "Chicago 1893" There's also a board game with an assortment of different houses for the board game on it. There is also A bowl of popcorn and a soda on the table
Keep It LocalAugust 20

Your Guide to Chicago’s Toy Stores

From vintage toys to a workshop series for aspiring toy inventors, Here's a list of places that’ll help you spoil the kids in your life a...

A table with an assortment of different stuffed animals
Keep It LocalAugust 13

Your Guide to Chicago’s Stationery Stores

Whether you’re actually going back to school soon or you just love analog hobbies, these local shops will help you find all kinds of stat...

A large group of people inside a store. They are looking at an assortment of items
Food & DrinkAugust 13

5 New Spots to Dine and Drink

Chicago is hot AF right now — and so is the dining scene. These recent openings have caught our eye.

A room with velvet drapes on every wall. On the ceiling there are chandeliers and people are sitting at a booth
Keep It LocalAugust 13

Family-Run Atlas Stationers Has Supplied Chicago’s Pens For Decades

For decades, the family-run shop delivered office supplies in bulk to offices in the Loop.

The outside of a brick building, the sign says "Atlas Stationers Inc"
Keep It LocalAugust 6

Your Guide to Dog-Friendly Patios

Want to enjoy patio weather, but hate leaving your pup at home? Check out our guide on the best dog-friendly patios in Chicago.

A curly-haired golden doodle wearing a harness steps into a small blue kiddie pool filled with colorful beach balls at a dog-friendly outdoor patio, with diners seated under blue and white striped umbrellas in the background.
Keep It LocalJuly 30

Why Creatives Love Epiphany Center for the Arts

Five years ago, a group of artists transformed a shuttered, historic church at 201 S. Ashland Ave. into Epiphany Center for the Arts. Sin...

An indoor space with hanging lights and a wood floor. The walls are short but the roof is very tall. There are small remnants of a church left like the windows