City Cast Chicago logo

Tough Grades for Mayor Brandon Johnson's First Year

Posted on May 20, 2024   |   Updated on September 30, 2025
Simone Alicea

Simone Alicea

A D- report card for Mayor Brandon Johnson

Hey Chicago readers and City Cast Chicago listeners gave the first-term mayor a D- 😬 (City Cast Chicago)

City Cast

Why Mayor Brandon Johnson Won't Grade His First Year

00:00:00

After the City Cast Chicago podcast talked with Mayor Brandon Johnson last week, we gave him about a C- grade on his first year in office.

City Cast

Trump Tower Tax Trouble, Mayor’s Grades, and a Cicada Costume

00:00:00

The main reasons for low marks? Concerns about crime, transit, migrants, transparency, and overall leadership. Here’s what you said about his performance.

A pie chart showing nearly half of Hey Chicago readers gave Mayor Brandon Johnson a failing grade

Nearly half of readers and listeners who participated in our survey gave a failing grade. (City Cast Chicago)

Grade F

Colette W.: “He bumbles along and ‘reacts’ versus instituting proactive policies regarding crime, especially in high-tourist areas and city central neighborhoods.”

Grade D

Hannah F.: “Failure to accomplish anything of note, while serious issues continue to get worse. The state of public transit is my biggest concern, and he’s been atrocious in my opinion.”

City Cast

CTA Investigation, Counting Migrant Students, and Bears Stadium Plans

00:00:00

Sten T.: “As someone who voted for and knocked doors for [Johnson], I want to know who he’s listening to because it’s not the people who showed up for him a year ago.”

City Cast

Brandon Johnson Says Chicago Needs a Teacher at City Hall

00:00:00

Grade C

Hilary M.: “I think he has focused on less urgent matters and allowed himself to be manipulated (e.g. the ridiculous request for a new [Bears] stadium).”

City Cast

CTA Investigation, Counting Migrant Students, and Bears Stadium Plans

00:00:00

Matt M.: “I think overall there have been some progressive wins that were promised, but some administrative bumbling that has been disappointing.”

Grade B

Viral M.: “Ending tipped minimum wage … passed a huge housing bond deal to wean us off TIFs … took cops out of schools … reopened the Department of Environment … I think he needs to be better about communications and transparency in general, but he’s following through on a lot of the things he said he’d do.”

City Cast

Why is Chicago Always Talking About TIF?

00:00:00

Share article

Hey Chicago

Stay connected to City Cast Chicago and get ready to join the local conversation.

Can't subscribe? Turn off your ad blocker and try again.

The latest in Chicago

Neighborhood GuidesSeptember 16

7 New Spots to Dine and Drink

Seven recently opened bars and Restaurants in Chicago

Two people at a table holding up their drinks. On the table there's a martini with olives.
Chicago, ExplainedSeptember 15

The Latest Candidates Running For Mayor

Mayor Brandon Johnson officially launched his reelection campaign, joining a race that includes roughly a dozen other challengers.

A composite photo of three people. On the left is a man in glasses and a dark suit. In the middle is a man in a blue suit, on the right is a woman wearing blue feathers and with white hair
Chicago, ExplainedSeptember 11

Take This Week's Chicago News Trivia Quiz

How closely were you paying attention to this week's current events in Chicago? Test yourself in our weekly trivia quiz.

A large brick building with glass roof and intricate metal on the corners
Keep It LocalSeptember 10

Sheep Cult Comics Celebrates Local Chicago Comic Artists

Stepping into Sheep Cult Comics, you’re surrounded by whimsical, winding caverns of cloud-like shelves, presided over by sculpted sheep h...

A large entrance in a store in the shape of a sheep. There are books along both sides of it
Keep It LocalSeptember 10

Your Guide To Chicago’s Comic Book Stores

I’ve compiled a list of stores where you can find the newest graphic novels, affordable used comics, or even your next favorite board gam...

Comics on display in what looks to be a multicolored customized bookshelf
Chicago, ExplainedSeptember 8

Mayor Brandon Johnson Answers YOUR Tough Questions

Mayor Brandon Johnson told City Cast Chicago he’ll announce whether he’s running again Sept. 13. And that’s not all he said. We sat down...

Two men sitting across from each other at a table looking at the camera. The man on the left has his arms crossed and is holding a piece of paper. The man on the right has a suit on and is showing a peace sign
Keep It LocalSeptember 3

Your Guide To Karaoke Bars in Chicago

Whether your perfect karaoke night involves performing to an entire bar or renting a room for a more intimate experience, you’ve got opti...

A woman singing into a mic. A man is holding up what looks to be a tv screen
Keep It LocalSeptember 3

The Art of Karaoke

Karaoke is pretty serious business, and I want to make sure you know what you’re getting yourself into.

A woman singing into a mic with her finger pointed up. There's a man behind her holding a screen